SF Ice Cream Rankings


Bi-Rite Creamery

Yes, the creamery has way more selection than the prepacked pints you can find at their markets. Their ice cream is much airier than…

Mitchell's Ice Cream

Must go. This is the true local's joint, open since 1953. What it lacks in hipster appeal, it makes up for it with the best variety of…

Mr. and Mrs. Miscellaneous

Love their offbeat flavors that constantly rotate. They keep it simple but elegant, and their mint chocolate chip changed my life.…

Smitten Ice Cream

You can't help but be impressed by the onsite liquid nitrogen production, but in the end the ice cream just isn't good. It's cloyingly…

Humphry Slocombe

Pass. I really am confused as to how this place is so popular. Their base ice cream has crystals in it--this is basic 101 stuff that they…

Salt & Straw

Very similar to Humphrey in that they do 3-4 ingredient flavor combos that are Willy Wonky-esque. The texture is very creamy, but…

CREAM San Francisco

This is a bit of a novelty thing. You can build your own ice cream sandwich with a variety of flavors and cookies. But the ice cream is…

Copy these finds, create your own lists, and more, with your own free account.

Create Account

Sign In

Copy these finds, create your own lists, and more, in the iOS app.



© 2019–2020 Compelld, Inc.